You paid your premiums. You filed a claim. Now your insurer is fighting you. The Penalta Law Firm has been representing Florida policyholders against insurance companies for over 30 years — we know how they operate, and we know how to win.
Florida Insurance Dispute Attorney — When Insurance Companies Deny, Delay, or Underpay Your Claim
star4.89 Stars · 37 Reviews
mapServing Florida Statewide
By clicking ‘Continue’ you agree to our Terms & acknowledge our Privacy Policy. You agree to receive communications including calls, texts, and emails.
Resolving Insurance Disputes Starts With Knowing Your Rights as a Policyholder
Insurance disputes often arise at the worst possible time — after a hurricane, a car accident, a house fire, a serious injury. You’ve already been through something difficult. Then your insurance company denies your claim, disputes the value, drags out the claims process, or simply stops responding.
Every type of insurance — from auto insurance to commercial property to health insurance — creates its own set of insurance issues. Numerous insurance companies use delay tactics, policy provisions buried in fine print, and adjusters trained to minimize payouts. Insurers handle disputes and types of claims very differently depending on the policy — and they rely on policyholders not knowing the difference. Many policyholders don’t realize they have legal options — or they try to resolve the dispute on their own and settle for far less than they’re owed.
Your insurance company denied your claim without a valid reason
Your insurer is offering a settlement far below the actual value of your loss
Your insurance company is acting in bad faith — delaying unreasonably, misrepresenting your policy, or refusing to pay valid claims
You received a denial letter and don’t understand why
You’re in a dispute over insurance coverage and need to know what your policy actually entitles you to
A property damage claim has stalled and you’re getting nowhere with the adjuster
Insurance Dispute Attorney — Protecting Policyholders Against Insurance Companies Since 1993
Alexander Penalta, Esq. has handled a wide range of insurance disputes across Florida for over three decades. He knows how insurance companies use policy language to deny claims, how adjusters are trained to undervalue losses, and what it takes to force an insurer to honor its obligations.
The firm handles disputed insurance claims of all types — including property damage, auto insurance disputes, health insurance coverage disputes, and bad-faith insurance claims. Whether your matter needs to be resolved through direct negotiation, the state insurance department, arbitration, or litigation in state court or federal court, we know how to handle it. We take cases on a contingency basis where appropriate — meaning you pay nothing unless we recover.
Types of Insurance Disputes and Steps to Take
Understanding Your Insurance Policies and Coverage
Disputes often arise because insurance policies are written to be difficult to interpret. Policy provisions, exclusions, and definitions of covered events are frequently ambiguous — and insurance companies use that ambiguity against you. Understanding what your insurance coverage actually says — and what the law requires your insurer to do — is the first step in any disputed insurance matter.
Many insurance policies also contain mandatory arbitration clauses, appraisal provisions, and deadlines that policyholders don’t know about until it’s too late. State law governs how insurance companies must handle claims, respond to policyholders, and underwrite their policies. A broker who sold you a policy and the insurer who issued it may have different obligations. We review your policy, identify your rights, and tell you exactly what your insurer is and isn’t allowed to do. An experienced attorney who understands insurance law is often the difference between a denied claim and a recovered one.
Bad-Faith Insurance: When Your Insurance Company Is Acting Unlawfully
Bad-faith insurance occurs when an insurer unreasonably refuses to pay a valid claim, fails to investigate a claim properly, misrepresents the terms of the policy, or uses unfair insurance practices to avoid paying what it owes. Florida law imposes specific obligations on insurers — and when they violate those obligations, policyholders may be entitled to punitive damages beyond the value of the original claim.
If your insurance company is acting in bad faith, that changes the legal landscape significantly. We evaluate bad-faith claims in every insurance dispute we handle.
Resolving Insurance Disputes: Negotiation, Appraisal, and Arbitration
Steps to take in an insurance dispute depend on your policy and the type of claim. Many insurance policies require an appraisal process for property damage disputes — where each side hires an independent appraiser and a neutral arbitrator decides any differences. Other policies require arbitration through the American Arbitration Association before a lawsuit can be filed.
We handle these processes on your behalf — and we know how insurance companies use them. A claim may go through multiple rounds of review before an insurer’s final position is set. The insurance company’s internal process is designed to benefit the insurer — the company may continue to delay or deny even after you’ve escalated. If the insurance company still refuses to pay after exhausting internal remedies, litigation or mediation is the next step. An insurer may push for appraisal when it benefits them and resist it when it doesn’t. We understand the strategy and we use it against them.
When to File a Lawsuit Against Your Insurance Company
If your insurer continues to deny or underpay after you’ve exhausted the internal claims process and alternative dispute resolution options, filing a lawsuit may be your only path to fair compensation. We handle insurance litigation in Florida state court and federal court — including summary judgment motions, discovery, and trial.
We also work with the state insurance department and the insurance association governing your insurer’s conduct when regulatory complaints are appropriate. When you file a claim with an insurance company, document your claim number and every interaction — this record matters in high-stakes and high-profile disputes. If your insurer is acting unfairly, there are third-party regulatory options and, in appropriate cases, appellate remedies. The insurance market in Florida is heavily regulated for this reason — and we know how to use those regulations in your favor. Sometimes a formal complaint triggers the insurer to reconsider — and sometimes it’s necessary to document a pattern of misconduct that supports punitive damages.
Types of Insurance Claims We Handle
- Property damage disputes — hurricane, flood, fire, and water damage claims denied or underpaid
- Auto insurance disputes — uninsured/underinsured motorist claims, liability disputes, and coverage denials
- Health insurance coverage disputes — claim denials, coverage exclusions, and health plan disagreements
- Commercial disputes — business interruption, D&O coverage, and commercial general liability disputes
- Bad-faith insurance claims — when your insurer has acted unlawfully or with misconduct
- Personal injury lawyer referrals — when your insurance dispute intersects with a personal injury claim, we coordinate the full picture
How it Works
Call or Contact Us 24/7
Our intake team is available around the clock. Insurance deadlines are real — missing them can forfeit your right to recover. Call (386) 847-5335 or contact us online immediately.
Free Case Evaluation
We offer a free case evaluation for insurance disputes. We review your policy, your claim, and your insurer’s response — and tell you exactly what your rights are and what your case is worth.
We Fight for the Compensation You Deserve
Whether we’re handling your claim through negotiation, appraisal, arbitration, or litigation, we handle the full process. We work to protect your rights and recover what you’re owed — and we handle many cases on a contingency basis, so there’s no upfront cost.
Got questions?
Well, we’ve got answers
An insurance dispute arises when a policyholder and an insurance company disagree about whether a claim is covered, how much should be paid, or how the policy provisions apply to a particular loss. Insurance disputes often arise after property damage events, accidents, or health issues — when policyholders most need their coverage to work.
First, get the denial in writing and understand the reason given. Then contact an experienced insurance dispute attorney before you respond, appeal, or accept any settlement. The steps you take after a denial matter — and doing them wrong can limit your options. We offer a free case evaluation to help you understand where you stand.
Bad-faith insurance refers to conduct by an insurer that goes beyond a simple coverage dispute — including unreasonably denying valid claims, deliberately misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to conduct a proper investigation, or delaying payment without justification. Florida law allows policyholders to seek punitive damages and additional compensation when an insurance company is acting in bad faith.
We handle a wide range of insurance disputes — including property damage claims, auto insurance coverage disputes, health plan and health insurance coverage matters, commercial disputes involving business interruption and D&O coverage, and bad-faith insurance litigation. If your insurance company is fighting you, we can help.
Yes. If your insurer wrongfully denies or underpays your claim, you can file a lawsuit in state court or, in some cases, federal court. Many insurance policies also allow you to right to take your dispute to arbitration. We evaluate all options and recommend the path most likely to recover full compensation you deserve.
We handle many insurance dispute cases on a contingency basis — meaning you pay no attorney’s fees unless we recover. Contact us for a free case evaluation to discuss the specifics of your situation.
Florida has specific deadlines — called statutes of limitations — for insurance claims. The deadline varies depending on the type of claim and your policy terms. Some policies also impose shorter internal deadlines for reporting disputes. The sooner you contact legal assistance, the more options you have.
Your insurer has a legal team. You should too.
Insurance companies are not on your side — they are businesses designed to minimize payouts. When you file a claim, they have experienced adjusters, legal teams, and a deep familiarity with the claims process working against you. The Penalta Law Firm levels that playing field. We know how insurance companies use policy language, appraisal, and delay tactics — and we know how to force them to pay.