O’Barry v. Ocean World, S.A., No. 4D09-969 (Fla. 4th DCA Oct. 7, 2009)

Opinion of the Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal in Richard O’Barry v. Ocean World, S.A., No. 4D09-969, decided October 7, 2009, on certiorari review of discovery orders in Ocean World, S.A. v. Earth Island Institute, et al., Broward County Circuit Court Case No. 07-9966CA14. Alexander Penalta served as counsel for respondent Ocean World, S.A.

Download the opinion (PDF)

Related legal resources: Read about the firm’s animal-law and related litigation services. For primary-source research, see the Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal opinion archive. The public portal provides court or case-research context; it does not by itself establish a case outcome.

Alexander Penalta

Bringing over 30 years of experience in civil, criminal, and administrative litigation. His practice focuses on complex legal disputes, business litigation, regulatory compliance, licensing matters, and trial advocacy. His background includes service as a Florida administrative hearings officer and university-level educator.

See Full Bio